Monday, March 20 2017 12:29
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Former co-chair of OSCE Minsk Group: In Karabakh issue the balance of  advantage lies with Armenia

Former co-chair of OSCE Minsk Group: In Karabakh issue the balance of  advantage lies with Armenia

ArmInfo.The settlement of the Karabakh conflict - the hardest problem in the post-Soviet space - needs the political will of the two countries, Vyacheslav Trubnikov,  former Russian co-chair of the OSCE Minsk Group, former first deputy  foreign minister of Russia, head of the Foreign Intelligence Service,  says in an interview with haqqin.az. 

He thinks political will is the leaders' ability to take steps making  neither of the parties a winner. "It is necessary to look for  compromises," Trubnikov says, noting that the Armenian side has  always insisted and keeps assuring that the return of the seven  districts is an integral part of a comprehensive solution to the  Karabakh problem.      

When asked whether Armenia insists on determining Karabakh's status  outside Azerbaijan, Trubnikov replies that various options have been  discussed, but the Armenian side has always stated that it is not  going to give the territories just for fun. "Anyway, Armenians have  been upholding this idea and Azerbaijan has never agreed to an  independent status of Karabakh. Therefore, the problem has reached a  deadlock. Nevertheless, in the early 2000s the parties came close to  the settlement. In April 2000, we met in Key West (USA). Presidents  Heydar Aliyev and Robert Kocharyan even agreed on the provisions of  the peace agreement. For our part, we found the formula of using the  Lachin corridor as a link between Armenia and Karabakh, and Meghri -  as a link between Nakhijevan and Azerbaijan.  The international  community represented by the OSCE Minsk Group co-chair countries was  ready to fund this option of settlement through the IMF. In addition,  Armenia gave its consent to withdrawal of its units from the occupied  territories and both parties agreed to the interim status of  Nagorno-Karabakh. Unfortunately, this decision was either incomplete  or inconvenient for someone," he says. 

Trubnikov does not share the opinion that it is Russia that torpedoes  the peace agreement between Azerbaijan and Armenia. He thinks that  Russia, on the contrary, is doing everything possible to stop that  conflict and to establish peace on its southern borders. "I had never  received any instructions from the Kremlin to torpedo the conflict or  bring it to a standstill. Quite the opposite, I had always been  instructed to find settlement options," he notes. Trubnikov is  convinced that no pressure on either of the parties will give any  result. He thinks that the Armenian side has more advantages than  Azerbaijan, meaning that it holds control over Karabakh and the  surrounding territories. "Armenia will use its trump cards in the  talks.  Pressure will give an opposite effect. Therefore, it is  necessary to patiently persuade the sides to settle the conflict  peacefully. There is no alternative to the peaceful settlement of the  conflict. There is no military settlement. First of all, the two  sides' political will is needed," he says. 

He stresses the need to create an atmosphere of confidence. No  bellicose rhetoric should be used. "Any bellicose statements hinder  the settlement of the problem. The "no war no peace" situation is  extremely dangerous," he says.

The former co-chair of the OSCE Minsk Group is convinced that any  attempts to resolve the conflict in the military way will only  complicate the problem and probably make Azerbaijan lose some other  territories as well. "Russia, for its part, will do everything  possible to prevent resumption of military actions. After all, it is  a matter of our national security," he says, adding that as a  co-chair country of the OSCE Minsk Group, Russia will be looking for  settlement options. 

He thinks that there is no need to deploy peacekeepers in the  conflict zone. He also points out the problem of refugees. "In  addition to the problem of Azeri refugees, there is also the problem  of the Armenians of Baku and Sumgait, who had been driven out of  their homes long before the occupation of Azeri territories.   Therefore, this problem needs a comprehensive solution without  violating the sides' interests. Azerbaijanis and Armenians should  themselves come to a certain solution. You should finally understand  that it is not the problem of Putin, Trump or Hollande. It is the  problems of Azerbaijanis and Armenians! You should not shift your  problems on us. You should come to an agreement and we will willingly  help you. It is the problem of sustainable development of Azerbaijan  and Armenia, the welfare of their people. Therefore, they should be  interested in the settlement most of all," Trubnikov says. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Placido Domingo was the guest of honor at the gala concert in honor of Gegham GrigoryanPlacido Domingo was the guest of honor at the gala concert in honor of Gegham Grigoryan
UNESCO Director-General Khaled El-Enany visited the Zvartnots CathedralUNESCO Director-General Khaled El-Enany visited the Zvartnots Cathedral
The ARF Student Union criticized the Armenian authorities` intention to initiate an exchange program between Armenian and Turkish studentsThe ARF Student Union criticized the Armenian authorities` intention to initiate an exchange program between Armenian and Turkish students
Armenia and Kyrgyzstan called for further deepening of bilateral relationsArmenia and Kyrgyzstan called for further deepening of bilateral relations
Nikol Pashinyan and Sadyr Japarov held talks in YerevanNikol Pashinyan and Sadyr Japarov held talks in Yerevan
Yerevan and Bishkek became sister citiesYerevan and Bishkek became sister cities
Leonardo DiCaprio expressed support for a large-scale global initiative to protect endangered species, announced in YerevanLeonardo DiCaprio expressed support for a large-scale global initiative to protect endangered species, announced in Yerevan
The final games of the Roman Berezovsky Prize tournament have begun in the Armavir regionThe final games of the Roman Berezovsky Prize tournament have begun in the Armavir region
Happy holiday, city with soul and character - Russian House in GyumriHappy holiday, city with soul and character - Russian House in Gyumri
Armenia and UNESCO agreed to continue deepening bilateral cooperationArmenia and UNESCO agreed to continue deepening bilateral cooperation
"Strong Armenia" congratulated Gyumri on City Day
The Secretary General of the Armenian Ministry of Defense discussed strengthening integrity in the defense sector with a NATO representativeThe Secretary General of the Armenian Ministry of Defense discussed strengthening integrity in the defense sector with a NATO representative
Lawyer: House arrest of Fatherland Party Secretary General extended for three monthsLawyer: House arrest of Fatherland Party Secretary General extended for three months
Kopyrkin: Relations between Russia and Armenia are going through a phase that requires mutual understanding and a search for a new balance.Kopyrkin: Relations between Russia and Armenia are going through a phase that requires mutual understanding and a search for a new balance.
Armenia`s Minister of Environment discussed the COP17 agenda with his colleagues from China and Oman.Armenia`s Minister of Environment discussed the COP17 agenda with his colleagues from China and Oman.
Human rights activist: The Armenian government confirms that it has approached third countries regarding visits to Armenian prisoners of war, but denies receiving their consent.Human rights activist: The Armenian government confirms that it has approached third countries regarding visits to Armenian prisoners of war, but denies receiving their consent.
Kyrgyzstan is interested in adapting the Armenian educational model in its country.Kyrgyzstan is interested in adapting the Armenian educational model in its country.
Human rights activist: Torture of Armenian prisoners of war in Azerbaijan is endemicHuman rights activist: Torture of Armenian prisoners of war in Azerbaijan is endemic
The Armenian Prime Minister held meetings with the Director-General of UNESCO and the Vice-President of the European Commission.The Armenian Prime Minister held meetings with the Director-General of UNESCO and the Vice-President of the European Commission.
Delegation of Turkmenistan participated in the 77th session of the UNHCR Executive CommitteeDelegation of Turkmenistan participated in the 77th session of the UNHCR Executive Committee
Gevorg Parsyan will take part in the local government elections in Kapan.Gevorg Parsyan will take part in the local government elections in Kapan.
Official: Türkiye wants to strengthen peace, tranquility, and prosperity in the South CaucasusOfficial: Türkiye wants to strengthen peace, tranquility, and prosperity in the South Caucasus
The head of Armenia`s Ministry of Education, Science and Culture and the Secretary General of the International Federation of Francophonie discussed the country`s preparations for the 10th Francophonie Games.The head of Armenia`s Ministry of Education, Science and Culture and the Secretary General of the International Federation of Francophonie discussed the country`s preparations for the 10th Francophonie Games.
Araghchi is confident that Armenia is not taking any action against Iran`s securityAraghchi is confident that Armenia is not taking any action against Iran`s security
The heads of parliament of Armenia and Ukraine discussed the possibility of expanding interparliamentary tiesThe heads of parliament of Armenia and Ukraine discussed the possibility of expanding interparliamentary ties
Strong Armenia explained why they nominated a candidate for the local government elections only in StepanavanStrong Armenia explained why they nominated a candidate for the local government elections only in Stepanavan
The Catholicos of All Armenians thanked Save Armenia for its efforts to protect the rights of Armenians in ArtsakhThe Catholicos of All Armenians thanked Save Armenia for its efforts to protect the rights of Armenians in Artsakh
The Armenian Prime Minister and Iranian President compared notes on the bilateral cooperation agendaThe Armenian Prime Minister and Iranian President compared notes on the bilateral cooperation agenda
IDBank to Showcase Environmental and Innovative Initiatives at COP17IDBank to Showcase Environmental and Innovative Initiatives at COP17
The heads of parliament of Armenia and Moldova discussed the possibility of expanding interparliamentary cooperationThe heads of parliament of Armenia and Moldova discussed the possibility of expanding interparliamentary cooperation
The Speaker of the Armenian Parliament and the President of the OSCE PA compared notes on the bilateral cooperation agenda.The Speaker of the Armenian Parliament and the President of the OSCE PA compared notes on the bilateral cooperation agenda.
Pashinyan: The Armenian government feels a special responsibility to nature, because during difficult times, it was nature that saved the Armenian peoplePashinyan: The Armenian government feels a special responsibility to nature, because during difficult times, it was nature that saved the Armenian people
The NDP Council condemned the start of the Amulsar field`s operation, citing potential risksThe NDP Council condemned the start of the Amulsar field`s operation, citing potential risks
Armenia and France discussed cooperation in the defense sectorArmenia and France discussed cooperation in the defense sector
Deputy Prime Minister of Armenia: Concepts and procedures regarding the issue of enclaves-exclaves are clearly described and regulatedDeputy Prime Minister of Armenia: Concepts and procedures regarding the issue of enclaves-exclaves are clearly described and regulated
Mirzoyan: Armenia plans to continue its work within the EAEUMirzoyan: Armenia plans to continue its work within the EAEU
Pashinyan`s visit to Iran is on the agenda. Mirzoyan Pashinyan`s visit to Iran is on the agenda. Mirzoyan
The Armenian Ombudsman`s Office responded to a complaint filed by prisoner Armen SimonyanThe Armenian Ombudsman`s Office responded to a complaint filed by prisoner Armen Simonyan
Reuters has identified a conflict of interest in Sokolov`s appointment as chairman of the TRIPP+ Enterprise Fund.Reuters has identified a conflict of interest in Sokolov`s appointment as chairman of the TRIPP+ Enterprise Fund.
The newly appointed Consul General of Iran presented his exequatur to the Secretary General of the Armenian Foreign MinistryThe newly appointed Consul General of Iran presented his exequatur to the Secretary General of the Armenian Foreign Ministry
On the Edge of Meaning: Art Embassy to Present On the Edge of Meaning: Art Embassy to Present "Silence," a New Project by Artist Bagrat Arazyan
High-ranking foreign guests arrive in Armenia to participate in COP17High-ranking foreign guests arrive in Armenia to participate in COP17
The UN Secretary-General visited the MatenadaranThe UN Secretary-General visited the Matenadaran
The Minister of Defense ordered work to strengthen discipline in military units.The Minister of Defense ordered work to strengthen discipline in military units.
Tsarukyan`s lawyer: The guilty verdict ignored all exculpatory evidenceTsarukyan`s lawyer: The guilty verdict ignored all exculpatory evidence
Pashinyan and the OSCE Chairperson-in-Office discussed the peace process between Armenia and Azerbaijan.Pashinyan and the OSCE Chairperson-in-Office discussed the peace process between Armenia and Azerbaijan.
The Swiss Foreign Minister honored the memory of the victims of the Armenian Genocide.The Swiss Foreign Minister honored the memory of the victims of the Armenian Genocide.
Pashinyan and Mushikiwabo discussed preparations for the International Francophonie GamesPashinyan and Mushikiwabo discussed preparations for the International Francophonie Games
The head of Armenia`s Ministry of Education, Science and Culture and the French Ambassador discussed prospects for bilateral cooperation.The head of Armenia`s Ministry of Education, Science and Culture and the French Ambassador discussed prospects for bilateral cooperation.
The President of Kyrgyzstan will pay an official visit to Armenia.The President of Kyrgyzstan will pay an official visit to Armenia.
Armenia and UNDP signed a memorandum of cooperation in the field of parliamentary development for 2026-2031.Armenia and UNDP signed a memorandum of cooperation in the field of parliamentary development for 2026-2031.
A scientific conference on A scientific conference on "Armenian Folk and Decorative-Applied Arts" will be held in Yerevan and Dilijan.
The UN Secretary-General praised the excellent organization of COP17 in Armenia.The UN Secretary-General praised the excellent organization of COP17 in Armenia.
35 Years of Trust: IDBank Celebrates with Its Customers35 Years of Trust: IDBank Celebrates with Its Customers
A gas station in the Armenian capital, owned by the father-in-law of an opposition MP, is being dismantled despite having a permit to operateA gas station in the Armenian capital, owned by the father-in-law of an opposition MP, is being dismantled despite having a permit to operate
Lavrov: Russia is ready to participate in regional infrastructure projects in the South CaucasusLavrov: Russia is ready to participate in regional infrastructure projects in the South Caucasus
A meeting of the heads of the foreign affairs agencies of Turkmenistan, Azerbaijan, and Uzbekistan took place in BakuA meeting of the heads of the foreign affairs agencies of Turkmenistan, Azerbaijan, and Uzbekistan took place in Baku
The foreign ministers of Russia and Turkey were discussed the cooperation agenda at a meeting in Baku.The foreign ministers of Russia and Turkey were discussed the cooperation agenda at a meeting in Baku.
The Deputy Speaker of the Armenian Parliament and the President of the Chamber of Deputies of Luxembourg discussed prospects for developing bilateral cooperationThe Deputy Speaker of the Armenian Parliament and the President of the Chamber of Deputies of Luxembourg discussed prospects for developing bilateral cooperation
Switzerland expressed its readiness to facilitate the peace process between Armenia and AzerbaijanSwitzerland expressed its readiness to facilitate the peace process between Armenia and Azerbaijan
Read more



Commented
Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029Lukashenko called for Armenia to assume the CIS presidency in 2029
Dmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policyDmitry Medvedev predicted a Ukrainian-like fate for Armenia amid the country`s shift in foreign policy
Russian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assetsRussian Security Council: In Armenia, they want to force Russian asset owners to dispose of their assets
Zakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral tiesZakharova: Russia ready to discuss with Armenia the prospects for expanding military cooperation as part of a review of bilateral ties
Tevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global warTevanyan: Armenia, like Ukraine and Moldova, is being drawn into the EU’s global war
Yerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the cityYerevan City Hall is considering introducing a valet parking system in the city
Expert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocideExpert: The circus surrounding the “Albanization” of Armenian culture in the presence of foreign ambassadors in occupied Artsakh is genocide
Political scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s placePolitical scientist: If Russian-Armenian relations are destroyed, Turkey will take Russia`s place
Political scientist: The Armenian public is simply obliged to significantly change the entire content of public discourse and strugglePolitical scientist: The Armenian public is simply obliged to significantly change the entire content of public discourse and struggle
Cross tattoos are being removed from the skin of Christian prisoners in Azerbaijan by fire, according to a human rights activist.Cross tattoos are being removed from the skin of Christian prisoners in Azerbaijan by fire, according to a human rights activist.
Zakharova: Armenia`s likely introduction of visas with Russia will be a step against Yerevan itselfZakharova: Armenia`s likely introduction of visas with Russia will be a step against Yerevan itself
Putin: Armenia`s recognition of Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan in Prague has given Russia`s position on this issue an ambivalent characterPutin: Armenia`s recognition of Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan in Prague has given Russia`s position on this issue an ambivalent character
Putin: Armenia`s adoption of the law on EU accession means an announcement of its withdrawal from the Eurasian Economic UnionPutin: Armenia`s adoption of the law on EU accession means an announcement of its withdrawal from the Eurasian Economic Union
Medvedev: Yerevan will never become an EU member, but it will permanently damage relations with the Eurasian Economic Union, including with Moscow.Medvedev: Yerevan will never become an EU member, but it will permanently damage relations with the Eurasian Economic Union, including with Moscow.
Aram Vardevanyan: Public demands solutions, not apology scandals in  ParliamentAram Vardevanyan: Public demands solutions, not apology scandals in  Parliament