Tuesday, October 27 2020 17:40

Richard Giragosian: The Azerbaijani column`s advance is driven more  by political objectives in Baku than military science

Richard Giragosian: The Azerbaijani column`s advance is driven more  by political objectives in Baku than military science

ArmInfo.One month into a massive military offensive for Nagorno-Karabakh and hours into a failed US-brokered truce, Azerbaijan is facing a crucial choice that could define the  war's outcome, famous Armenian-Americanpolitical scientists Richard  Giragosian writes in his article published in Asia Times.

Azerbaijani troops, having advanced on the open terrain along the Iranian border,  have the momentum and appear to be fast approaching the strategic  Lachin corridor. But with its troops overstretched and the Karabakh  defenders having retreated to the forested high ground, Baku is at a  crossroads. The choice is one of following military logic and sound  strategy or opting instead for a decision with greater political and  diplomatic dividends. But Azerbaijan can't have it both ways.   Military logic suggests a choice of focusing on targeting the Lachin  corridor, the critical lifeline between Karabakh and Armenia. Any  success in cutting off the Lachin lifeline would be devastating,  endangering the resupply and flow of reinforcements to Karabakh and  subjecting the Karabakh Armenians to a months-long siege.  Yet for an  Azerbaijani populace eager for full control of Karabakh itself, that  would not be enough, as such a choice would be neither politically  palatable nor sufficient in the face of dangerously high expectations  for complete victory.

And that leaves the second choice: a turn away from the Lachin  corridor for an attack on the city of Shushi within Karabakh itself.   The capture of the historic cultural center of Shushi, known to  Azerbaijanis as Shusha, would offer significant political rewards for  the government of President Ilham Aliyev. It would also enhance  Baku's diplomatic bargaining power in any future negotiations.  Yet  such a move would also incur tremendous military losses and usher in  a new, even more intense period of guerrilla warfare as Karabakh  forces would hold an advantage in mobility and surprise in an  insurgency-style campaign against the Azerbaijani forces.  Given the  over-extended vulnerability and strained supply routes for the  Azerbaijani forces in the field for a month already, that may be an  especially risky decision.

Already, the Azerbaijani column - its advance driven more by  political objectives in Baku than military science - is inherently  vulnerable due to stretched supply lines and broken lines of  communication. This defiance of Clausewitzian military science may be  tempting in order to rush the advance and seize more territory, but  Baku is dangerously ignoring essential limitations and necessities.

In addition, the Azerbaijani attacking column is increasingly spread  much too thin, with no rear-guard deployment of units or men capable  of holding the territorial gains they have achieved in areas south of  Karabakh.

This weakness will only return as a looming challenge for the  Azerbaijani attackers as any counter-attacks by the Karabakh Armenian  forces will face little resistance and could offer a much-needed  element of tactical surprise and "out-flanking" of exposed  Azerbaijani units.  Winter is now fast approaching, meaning any  further Azerbaijani combat operations will be especially difficult if  not impossible in the coming weeks due to low visibility and  impassable snow-covered mountainous terrain.

A second, often overlooked factor in the strategic context is the  operational doctrine and combat experience of the Karabakh Armenian  side. In the major past confrontations, most notably the initial  Karabakh war of the early 1990s and the five-day war of April 2016,  the Karabakh Armenians were initially losing before regrouping and  securing victories based on counter-attacks and repelling invasions.

This historical pattern offers another advantage for the Karabakh  defensive position beyond the already important edge of terrain and  topography, suggesting the real burden is on the attackers.  Beyond  the daily reports of severe losses, high casualties and an  increasingly costly tactical campaign to both seize territory and  defend positions, it may be too early to discount the Karabakh  Armenian defenders.

After a weeks-long consistent Azerbaijani advance, a successful and  orderly retreat by the Karabakh forces allowed them to reposition and  regroup for a secondary defensive line based on the defenders'  advantages of terrain and topography.  After suffering serious losses  in equipment and nearly 1,000 casualties, their counter-attacks and  stubborn resistance have begun to turn the tide of battle.

In recent days, the new defensive positions succeeded in halting the  Azerbaijani advance to within roughly 25 kilometers of the  strategically vital Lachin corridor, the sole highway connection  between Karabakh and Armenia.

At the same time, the retreat into the mountains and forests have  allowed the Karabakh forces to launch small unit attacks against the  more exposed Azerbaijani infantry and armored support.  And with such  forested and mountainous terrain, the Azerbaijani advantage of an air  threat from their formidable Turkish and Israeli military drones will  be significantly diminished.  Yet with President Aliyev having  promising full victory, the prospect of stopping short of either  Lachin or Shushi could risk political suicide.

Against this backdrop, even tripartite diplomatic engagement has  fallen short. Moscow, in an attempt to demonstrate its diplomatic  dominance, sought to force an agreement on the Armenian and  Azerbaijani foreign ministers in a hastily arranged meeting on  October 9.  Backed by France and the United States, the two other  co-chairing nations of the Organization for Security and Cooperation  in Europe's (OSCE) so-called Minsk Group, this Russian initiative was  initially seen as a potent assertion of diplomatic power.

Yet both Azerbaijan and Turkey showed uncharacteristic courage in  resisting what they saw as Russian bluff and bluster, and the  Azerbaijani offensive continued unencumbered.

Such open and outright defiance of Russia stems from an Azerbaijani  determination fortified by an unprecedented level of direct Turkish  military and diplomatic support. Azerbaijani military gains in  territory and tactical success against the Karabakh Armenian  defenders have only deepened their reluctance to abide by a  ceasefire.

In the wake of that rather surprising rebuke, a second diplomatic  initiative was launched. This time it was France, in a round of  American- style, shuttle diplomacy, with an emissary of French  President Emmanuel Macron flying into Yerevan and on to Baku for a  series of meetings with each side on October 15-16.  Despite  accolades for innovation and initiative, that second effort at  securing a ceasefire also fell short.

Emboldened by territorial gains and encouraged by popular domestic  support rare for his authoritarian rule, President Aliyev flouted his  newfound victories and echoed Turkish complaints of the OSCE Minsk  Group, suggesting a greater role for Ankara in the mediation at the  expense of Paris.

And in the weakest and least promising round of diplomatic  engagement, US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo met separately with the  Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers in Washington on October  23.

This belated American gesture was largely doomed from the start, and  was as much a move to show geopolitical relevance as to boost an  embattled Trump administration in the waning days of a contested  presidential election campaign.

While the US did succeed in securing an agreement to abide by yet  another cessation of hostilities, it already appeared to break down  within an hour of implementation.

Conflict mediation is never an easy task, dependent on a degree of  sincere political will among the parties to the conflict, and in  nearly all cases, a degree of conflict fatigue. In the case of  Nagorno-Karabakh, war-time diplomacy has failed, with dynamic  developments on the battlefield now driving the situation. 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
The Compulsory Enforcement Service of Armenia confirmed the detention of its employee.The Compulsory Enforcement Service of Armenia confirmed the detention of its employee.
Mirzoyan took part in the EU ministerial meeting on Mirzoyan took part in the EU ministerial meeting on "Interregional Security and Connectivity"
Pashinyan`s allies held talks with the French ambassador.Pashinyan`s allies held talks with the French ambassador.
Robert Abajyan, whose name has become a symbol of exceptional courage, military valor, and devotion to his homeland, would have turned 30 today.Robert Abajyan, whose name has become a symbol of exceptional courage, military valor, and devotion to his homeland, would have turned 30 today.
Medvedev: Electoral processes have become a new global arena for international confrontationMedvedev: Electoral processes have become a new global arena for international confrontation
Republican: Artsakh is occupied today and the struggle of the people of Artsakh today is for the freedom of nations, which will defeat the occupationRepublican: Artsakh is occupied today and the struggle of the people of Artsakh today is for the freedom of nations, which will defeat the occupation
The Ministry of Labor of Armenia: For Artsakh residents forcibly displaced in 2020, the validity of housing certificates has been extended until July 2027.The Ministry of Labor of Armenia: For Artsakh residents forcibly displaced in 2020, the validity of housing certificates has been extended until July 2027.
Armenia and the EU discussed defense cooperationArmenia and the EU discussed defense cooperation
The foreign ministers of Armenia and Greece compared notes on the bilateral cooperation agenda.The foreign ministers of Armenia and Greece compared notes on the bilateral cooperation agenda.
Former Armenian Justice Minister: Removing the Declaration of Independence from the Armenian Constitution at Azerbaijan`s request will lead to international sanctionsFormer Armenian Justice Minister: Removing the Declaration of Independence from the Armenian Constitution at Azerbaijan`s request will lead to international sanctions
The Television and Radio Commission is expressing concern over the policy of the public service station where a fight involving obscene language broke out yesterday.The Television and Radio Commission is expressing concern over the policy of the public service station where a fight involving obscene language broke out yesterday.
Aregnaz Manukyan`s daughter shared her experiences from the Armenian parliament rostrum following her mother`s arrest.Aregnaz Manukyan`s daughter shared her experiences from the Armenian parliament rostrum following her mother`s arrest.
Gohar Meloyan proposed establishing parliamentary oversight over the circumstances of Arsen Gevorkyan`s deathGohar Meloyan proposed establishing parliamentary oversight over the circumstances of Arsen Gevorkyan`s death
The Deputy Speaker of the National Assembly of Armenia, at a meeting with the head of the CoE delegation, addressed the challenges facing the rule of law and democracyThe Deputy Speaker of the National Assembly of Armenia, at a meeting with the head of the CoE delegation, addressed the challenges facing the rule of law and democracy
Kobakhidze: The first meeting of special representatives of Georgia and Russia after the break will take place very soonKobakhidze: The first meeting of special representatives of Georgia and Russia after the break will take place very soon
The mayor of Yerevan proposed a number of restrictions to relieve traffic congestion.The mayor of Yerevan proposed a number of restrictions to relieve traffic congestion.
The head of the Investigative Committee of Armenia left for an official visit to TehranThe head of the Investigative Committee of Armenia left for an official visit to Tehran
Following the summit in Cambodia, the International Forum adopted a resolution in support of progress in the Armenian-Azerbaijani peace process.Following the summit in Cambodia, the International Forum adopted a resolution in support of progress in the Armenian-Azerbaijani peace process.
The leader of The leader of "Hayakve" proposed that the Armenian opposition legislate a ban on the widespread use of arrests.
Georgia has handed over a citizen suspected of committing murder to ArmeniaGeorgia has handed over a citizen suspected of committing murder to Armenia
Oppositionist: More than half of Armenia`s 3,276 prisoners are held without a sentenceOppositionist: More than half of Armenia`s 3,276 prisoners are held without a sentence
Armenian citizens who have not completed military service will have the right to work as police officers or rescuersArmenian citizens who have not completed military service will have the right to work as police officers or rescuers
Armenia will tighten penalties for traffic violations that lead to traffic congestionArmenia will tighten penalties for traffic violations that lead to traffic congestion
The introduction of mandatory individual licensing for healthcare workers in Armenia will be postponedThe introduction of mandatory individual licensing for healthcare workers in Armenia will be postponed
The Prosecutor General of Armenia discussed cooperation with the Prosecutor General of the Autonomous City of Buenos AiresThe Prosecutor General of Armenia discussed cooperation with the Prosecutor General of the Autonomous City of Buenos Aires
Judge Artur Vagharshyan has been elected Vice-Chairman of the Constitutional Court of ArmeniaJudge Artur Vagharshyan has been elected Vice-Chairman of the Constitutional Court of Armenia
MP: When it comes to citizens` health, all disagreements between the authorities and opposition forces should fade into the backgroundMP: When it comes to citizens` health, all disagreements between the authorities and opposition forces should fade into the background
The National Assembly Commission has given its approval for the ratification of Article 11 of the Revised European Social CharterThe National Assembly Commission has given its approval for the ratification of Article 11 of the Revised European Social Charter
Georgia was not invited to the EU Enlargement ForumGeorgia was not invited to the EU Enlargement Forum
With grant support from the Netherlands, new technologies will be introduced in literary museums in ArmeniaWith grant support from the Netherlands, new technologies will be introduced in literary museums in Armenia
Armenia will increase the maximum age for conscription from 27 to 32 yearsArmenia will increase the maximum age for conscription from 27 to 32 years
Narek Karapetyan: Azerbaijan will continue to delay the peace process as long as it sees an opportunity to extract concessions from ArmeniaNarek Karapetyan: Azerbaijan will continue to delay the peace process as long as it sees an opportunity to extract concessions from Armenia
A security sphere expert commented on a video about Papikyan`s achievements during his five years as Defense MinisterA security sphere expert commented on a video about Papikyan`s achievements during his five years as Defense Minister
The Days of Armenian Culture concluded in MoscowThe Days of Armenian Culture concluded in Moscow
A human rights activist called the showing of video footage of the fight at the OTA pavilion an attempt to humiliate journalist Boris MuraziA human rights activist called the showing of video footage of the fight at the OTA pavilion an attempt to humiliate journalist Boris Murazi
The Prosecutors General of Armenia and Dubai discussed the development of bilateral cooperationThe Prosecutors General of Armenia and Dubai discussed the development of bilateral cooperation
The Prime Ministers of Armenia and Cambodia discussed the development of relations between the two countriesThe Prime Ministers of Armenia and Cambodia discussed the development of relations between the two countries
The Ministry of Internal Affairs of Armenia: From November 14, expedited biometric passport and ID card processing services are availableThe Ministry of Internal Affairs of Armenia: From November 14, expedited biometric passport and ID card processing services are available
The Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia visited the Armenian pavilion opened in the Francophonie area in Phnom PenhThe Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia visited the Armenian pavilion opened in the Francophonie area in Phnom Penh
The Armenian National Congress (ANC) expressed its condolences over the death of former Armenian parliament member Myasnik MalkhasyanThe Armenian National Congress (ANC) expressed its condolences over the death of former Armenian parliament member Myasnik Malkhasyan
Armenia congratulated Palestine on Independence DayArmenia congratulated Palestine on Independence Day
Meeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan with the Secretary-General of the Economic Cooperation OrganizationMeeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan with the Secretary-General of the Economic Cooperation Organization
The Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia participated in the 48th session of the Ministerial Conference of La FrancophonieThe Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia participated in the 48th session of the Ministerial Conference of La Francophonie
A group of PACE deputies expressed concern over the arrest of <Strong Armenia> leader Samvel KarapetyanA group of PACE deputies expressed concern over the arrest of leader Samvel Karapetyan
The Artsakh State Minister proposes creating a trilateral negotiating committee to discuss the release of prisonersThe Artsakh State Minister proposes creating a trilateral negotiating committee to discuss the release of prisoners
Armenia and Russia discussed the possibility of integrating the RAU research unit into the infrastructure of the Academic CityArmenia and Russia discussed the possibility of integrating the RAU research unit into the infrastructure of the Academic City
The Minister of Education, Science, Culture and Sports of Armenia took part in the 2nd Russian-Armenian Educational ForumThe Minister of Education, Science, Culture and Sports of Armenia took part in the 2nd Russian-Armenian Educational Forum
Pashinyan: Armenia and Turkey are close to fully normalizing relationsPashinyan: Armenia and Turkey are close to fully normalizing relations
Peace and normalization of Armenian-Azerbaijani relations are the only way to resolve the prisoner issue, says PashinyanPeace and normalization of Armenian-Azerbaijani relations are the only way to resolve the prisoner issue, says Pashinyan
Pashinyan will attend the 20th summit of the International Organization of Francophonie in CambodiaPashinyan will attend the 20th summit of the International Organization of Francophonie in Cambodia
Armenia and Russia signed a Program of Cooperation in the Sphere of Culture for 2027-2029.Armenia and Russia signed a Program of Cooperation in the Sphere of Culture for 2027-2029.
Pashinyan announced a visit to RussiaPashinyan announced a visit to Russia
The Ministry of Defense held an operational meeting of the leadership of the department and the Armed ForcesThe Ministry of Defense held an operational meeting of the leadership of the department and the Armed Forces
A delegation from the Armenian Ministry of Defense participated in the 46th World Congress of Military MedicineA delegation from the Armenian Ministry of Defense participated in the 46th World Congress of Military Medicine
Armenia and Russia have identified key areas of scientific and educational cooperation.Armenia and Russia have identified key areas of scientific and educational cooperation.
Fans from Armenia and Cyprus honored the historical memory of their two nations at a match in Yerevan.Fans from Armenia and Cyprus honored the historical memory of their two nations at a match in Yerevan.
From Dream to Reality: IDBank’s Special Mortgage Terms at TOON EXPO.Invest 2026                From Dream to Reality: IDBank’s Special Mortgage Terms at TOON EXPO.Invest 2026            
IDBank Presents the Rate.Trading Digital Platform at Toon Expo.Invest 2026IDBank Presents the Rate.Trading Digital Platform at Toon Expo.Invest 2026
The judge who arrested Arsen Gevorkyan, who died in pretrial detention, has recused himself from the case.The judge who arrested Arsen Gevorkyan, who died in pretrial detention, has recused himself from the case.
The EU has handed over a second mine-clearing vehicle to Armenia.The EU has handed over a second mine-clearing vehicle to Armenia.
Read more



Commented