Arminfo.info


 Monday, August 21 2023 16:55
Marianna Mkrtchyan

Former state minister of Artsakh sees three scenarios of resolving  crisis round Artsakh

Former state minister of Artsakh sees three scenarios of resolving  crisis round Artsakh

ArmInfo. In an interview with Caucasus Watch, former state minister of Artsakh Ruben Vardanyan  spoke of three scenarios of resolving the crisis round Artsakh

In response to a question as to where he sees Karabakh 20 years from  now, Mr Vardanyan said: 

"We have established a movement that supports the 'Artsakh 2035  Vision.' Of course, nothing will come easily. We aim to live in our  own homeland, and there are several potential scenarios to achieve  this goal. It is an arduous journey, replete with obstacles, but we  draw inspiration from world history and analogous cases that  demonstrate such movements can persist for decades. We are prepared  to undertake this path with ample determination and resilience.

"Our vision is to defend our homeland. From our side, I see a great  determination for people to stay and take a stand. A change in the  Armenian government could bring a greater political alignment between  Armenia and Artsakh. There may also be greater involvement by  international actors. Therefore, the first scenario we are  considering as quite possible for the next 30-to-50 years is status  quo maintenance.

"This would be maintained by both sides: on the one hand, I do not  see how the local population can accept to live as an Azerbaijani  ethnic minority; on the other hand, a subdued Artsakh - that would  wish to unite with Armenia - is a useful trigger of 'perpetual  national emergency' that is convenient for the Aliyev regime.  Nevertheless, the dream for unification continues to persist. If  these assumptions hold, the new normal will be periods of conflict  with intervals of relative stability. We will maintain the status  quo, dynamically."

The second scenarios is, according to Mr Vardanyan, the one involving  the satellite-like integration of Artsakh into Russia.

Different circles envision an alternative scenario that goes beyond  maintaining the status quo -Russia is the West's adversary today and  that would affect how the West sees Artsakh in this scenario. But we  are talking about 20 years from now. Do we believe that Russia will  remain an adversary to the West? 

"A third scenario entails an 'international mandate' or intervention  by external powers, providing certain security guarantees. South  Caucusus was always viewed by the West and the rest as Russia's  domain. West delegated South Caucuses security to Russia. It could be  changing now. Iran is highly likely to move in to balance  Azerbaijani-Israeli alliance in the region. Reminding you, Iran has  better relations today with Ankara (NATO member) than with Baku. If  Iran becomes a security guarantor in the Caucasus. How would the West  react to that?

"However, it's crucial for people to recognize that the future rests  in our hands. We cannot merely stand by and debate others' scenarios;  we must formulate our own plan and narrative. I believe assuming  responsibility and actively shaping our future is paramount.  Important note. Armenia and Artsakh might be young democracies, but  they are still democracies sandwiched between mighty Turkey,  Azerbaijan, Russia and Iran. I do not see Armenians being subjected  to limitations of their human rights and freedoms willingly or submit  to power without putting up dignified resistance.

"But it is very important for people to realize that the future is in  their hands. And with their own actions, they can have an impact on  these scenarios; indeed, they can insist on and achieve the  implementation of their own scenario," Mr Vardanyan said.  

Asked whether he sees three scenarios: status quo maintenance with a  view to eventual unification with Armenia, or Russian satellisation,  or an international mandate, presumably like the status of Palestine  before the establishment of the State of Israel, Mr Vardanyan answer  in the affirmative. 

Although the situation is undoubtedly very challenging, Mr Vardanyan  does not think that Azerbaijan is preparing to initiate another  large-scale military operation after Autumn 2020. 

"Having said that, we need to understand that Azerbaijan is shooting  civilians who work in the fields on a daily basis. Furthermore, they  tend to prefer small-scale local operations, which help maintain a  sense of tension and fear among the people regarding potential  military actions.

"The blockade is exerting both humanitarian and economic impacts. The  military threat appears intended to affect us psychologically.  However, I am not convinced that they are inclined towards an  aggressive scenario. They employ various tactics to subdue us, waging  a hybrid war on multiple fronts- informational, psychological, moral,  economic, and involving numerous other factors. They use the  humanitarian crisis as a weapon to reach political goals. The food  issue is weaponized and used against us," he said.

"Those who believe that Azerbaijan only desires Nagorno-Karabakh are  gravely mistaken; their recent aggressive actions towards Armenia  proper have demonstrated the opposite. Aliyev is deeply convinced  that he will always remain unpunished, leading him to resort to the  use of force or threats of force. On a daily basis, their media  prepares the groundwork for this. Their insatiable appetite for more  will eventually turn against them, sooner or later," Mr Vardanyan  said. 

The full interview is available here:  https://caucasuswatch.de/en/interviews/ruben-vardanyan-no-matter-  what-there-will-be-resistance.html

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Zakharova criticizes proposed Armenian electoral reforms regarding  Zakharova criticizes proposed Armenian electoral reforms regarding  "residency requirements"
"National Values" will appear in Georgian textbooks, including quotes from Ilia II.
Armenian President signs several military appointment decreesArmenian President signs several military appointment decrees
Financial Technology as a Sales Engine: IDBank Presented Its Fintech Ecosystem at Mantashyants Global Business Forum 2026Financial Technology as a Sales Engine: IDBank Presented Its Fintech Ecosystem at Mantashyants Global Business Forum 2026
MESCS reviews fresco restoration progress at Harichavank MonasteryMESCS reviews fresco restoration progress at Harichavank Monastery
"Georgian Dream": As a sovereign and independent state, Georgia has  the right to have relations with all states in its neighborhood
Lawyer: Prosperous Armenia Party overcame 4% threshold, but was  excluded from parliament due to actions of CECLawyer: Prosperous Armenia Party overcame 4% threshold, but was  excluded from parliament due to actions of CEC
"Strong Armenia": Citizens expect  Constitutional Court to serve  interests of  Armenian people and democracy
NA Vice Speaker: Armenia strives to deepen relations with the EUNA Vice Speaker: Armenia strives to deepen relations with the EU
RA Prime Minister: Institutional development of  State Protection  Service is essentialRA Prime Minister: Institutional development of  State Protection  Service is essential
Armenia, WFP discuss food security and cooperation within COP17  framework Armenia, WFP discuss food security and cooperation within COP17  framework 
Investigative body files motion to extend detention of political  prisoner Armen Ashotyan by two months — lawyerInvestigative body files motion to extend detention of political  prisoner Armen Ashotyan by two months — lawyer
Pashinyan`s spouse  participates in  annual Global Academy for First  Ladies and Gentlemen in New YorkPashinyan`s spouse  participates in  annual Global Academy for First  Ladies and Gentlemen in New York
Pashinyan and Mishustin discuss current issues of Russian-Armenian  cooperationPashinyan and Mishustin discuss current issues of Russian-Armenian  cooperation
Victims of cybercrime and financial fraud  protest outside Armenian  Government buildingVictims of cybercrime and financial fraud  protest outside Armenian  Government building
Armenian Ombudsperson facilitates prison visit for hunger-striking  inmate Hayk Stepanyan Armenian Ombudsperson facilitates prison visit for hunger-striking  inmate Hayk Stepanyan 
RA Prime Minister: Confiscation of illegal assets is one of the most  important pillars of anti-corruption policyRA Prime Minister: Confiscation of illegal assets is one of the most  important pillars of anti-corruption policy
"Wings of Unity": Declaration of all expenses by Pashinyan`s party  would have led to revocation of their candidate list
Armenia currently not conducting any negotiations with Russia on  TRIPP project - RA MFAArmenia currently not conducting any negotiations with Russia on  TRIPP project - RA MFA
 Armenian authorities clarified purpose of introducing IMEI  registration system amid public outcry Armenian authorities clarified purpose of introducing IMEI  registration system amid public outcry
Two MPs running for Armenia`s ruling parliamentary faction leader Two MPs running for Armenia`s ruling parliamentary faction leader 
Armenia plans to introduce medical reexaminations for conscripts  previously found unfit for military serviceArmenia plans to introduce medical reexaminations for conscripts  previously found unfit for military service
 With EU support, sixth regional youth space opened in Armenia With EU support, sixth regional youth space opened in Armenia
 Many cases brought against Strong Armenia dismissed, but nothing  announced - lawyer  Many cases brought against Strong Armenia dismissed, but nothing  announced - lawyer 
If case of new elections, Armenian authorities unable use as much  administrative resource - lawyer If case of new elections, Armenian authorities unable use as much  administrative resource - lawyer 
RA premier makes number of personnel changesRA premier makes number of personnel changes
Georgian Interior Minister inspects patrol service and operational  control center of ArmeniaGeorgian Interior Minister inspects patrol service and operational  control center of Armenia
Armenia attaches great importance to continued development of  friendly relations with Canada - RA premier Armenia attaches great importance to continued development of  friendly relations with Canada - RA premier 
RA Human Rights Defender, Estonian Prosecutor General discuss legal  reforms and protection from discrimination in YerevanRA Human Rights Defender, Estonian Prosecutor General discuss legal  reforms and protection from discrimination in Yerevan
Armenian authorities are not shortening military training period for  reservists because they view it as punitive instrument - opposition  rep Armenian authorities are not shortening military training period for  reservists because they view it as punitive instrument - opposition  rep 
RA ambassador discusses humanitarian crisis in Lebanon with Lebanese  officialRA ambassador discusses humanitarian crisis in Lebanon with Lebanese  official
High public expectations accompanied by annual increase in public  trust in Prosecutor`s Office - RA Prosecutor Gen High public expectations accompanied by annual increase in public  trust in Prosecutor`s Office - RA Prosecutor Gen 
Erdogan rejects Israel`s Armenian genocide move and points to Gaza  deathsErdogan rejects Israel`s Armenian genocide move and points to Gaza  deaths
RA MFA Sec Gen, Bundestag delegation advocates for development of  business ties between two countriesRA MFA Sec Gen, Bundestag delegation advocates for development of  business ties between two countries
 RA Government guarantees high salaries for CC justices, Syunik  families deprived of family benefits - politician  RA Government guarantees high salaries for CC justices, Syunik  families deprived of family benefits - politician 
Minister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan held a meeting with the UN Resident Coordinator in TurkmenistanMinister of Foreign Affairs of Turkmenistan held a meeting with the UN Resident Coordinator in Turkmenistan
Georgia`s Interior Minister visits Tsitsernakaberd memorial complexGeorgia`s Interior Minister visits Tsitsernakaberd memorial complex
Armenia and Georgia highlight  strong bilateral cooperation in  internal securityArmenia and Georgia highlight  strong bilateral cooperation in  internal security
Armenia and Latvia discuss cooperation in criminal justiceArmenia and Latvia discuss cooperation in criminal justice
World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH) to evaluate Armenia`s  veterinary servicesWorld Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH) to evaluate Armenia`s  veterinary services
Nikol Pashinyan receives Georgian Interior MinisterNikol Pashinyan receives Georgian Interior Minister
Chairman of Armenia`s Supreme Judicial Council discusses new  cooperation avenues with ADBChairman of Armenia`s Supreme Judicial Council discusses new  cooperation avenues with ADB
Media: Pashinyan to attend Khamenei`s funeral ceremonyMedia: Pashinyan to attend Khamenei`s funeral ceremony
Armenian authorities extend temporary visa-free travel for several  countries until July 1, 2027Armenian authorities extend temporary visa-free travel for several  countries until July 1, 2027
Official: Armenia planning to use its representation at COP17 to  foster international cooperation on ocean conservationOfficial: Armenia planning to use its representation at COP17 to  foster international cooperation on ocean conservation
Samvel Karapetyan: The opposition has a Samvel Karapetyan: The opposition has a "secret plan" to remove  Pashinyan from power in Armenia
 "Strong Armenia": Government combating poverty only  on paper
Moscow Park to be renovated: A Gift to Yerevan on IDBank`s 35th AnniversaryMoscow Park to be renovated: A Gift to Yerevan on IDBank`s 35th Anniversary
Investor Day 2026. LFG Brings Together International Investment Companies,  Financial Institutions, Investors, and AnalystsInvestor Day 2026. LFG Brings Together International Investment Companies,  Financial Institutions, Investors, and Analysts
Armenian Prime Minister discusses regional stability and peace with  EU AmbassadorsArmenian Prime Minister discusses regional stability and peace with  EU Ambassadors
Armenian medical teams to receive WHO-recognized certification for  emergency responseArmenian medical teams to receive WHO-recognized certification for  emergency response
Deputy Interior Minister addresses allegations regarding 100,000  passports on election dayDeputy Interior Minister addresses allegations regarding 100,000  passports on election day
No grounds for annulling parliamentary election results - minister No grounds for annulling parliamentary election results - minister 
Admission to high schools in Armenia to be held online for first time  and consist of two stages - ministry Admission to high schools in Armenia to be held online for first time  and consist of two stages - ministry 
RA Constitutional Courtvery busy due to large number of appeals  regarding Armenian elections results - Artak ZeynalyanRA Constitutional Courtvery busy due to large number of appeals  regarding Armenian elections results - Artak Zeynalyan
RA Deputy FM delivers remarks at high-level round table discussion  entitled RA Deputy FM delivers remarks at high-level round table discussion  entitled "Crimes That Affect the Environment: Threats to a  Sustainable Future" 
Citizens of Azerbaijan and Armenia to be able to confidentially  provide information about missing personsCitizens of Azerbaijan and Armenia to be able to confidentially  provide information about missing persons
Armenia plans to regulate destruction of counterfeit and expired  medicationsArmenia plans to regulate destruction of counterfeit and expired  medications
RA Constitutional Court to rule on opposition applications  challenging Armenian elections results by July 4RA Constitutional Court to rule on opposition applications  challenging Armenian elections results by July 4
Medicine quality and safety controls to be strengthened in ArmeniaMedicine quality and safety controls to be strengthened in Armenia
Read more



Commented
 Zakharova: Armenia`s pro-EU pivot poses economic security risks to  EAEU member states Zakharova: Armenia`s pro-EU pivot poses economic security risks to  EAEU member states
It`s time for South Caucasus countries to think of South Caucasus as  single, unified region - RA premier It`s time for South Caucasus countries to think of South Caucasus as  single, unified region - RA premier 
Pashinyan: Armenia and Azerbaijan should leave each other alonePashinyan: Armenia and Azerbaijan should leave each other alone
Moscow sees situation with Armenia as attempt to attack  Russia-involving integration associations - Russian presidential aidMoscow sees situation with Armenia as attempt to attack  Russia-involving integration associations - Russian presidential aid
Zakharova: Armenia views relations with Russia as tool for  financially securing reorientation toward EUZakharova: Armenia views relations with Russia as tool for  financially securing reorientation toward EU
The Armenian Minister of Justice and the EU Ambassador discussed visa liberalization issues for Yerevan.The Armenian Minister of Justice and the EU Ambassador discussed visa liberalization issues for Yerevan.
Azerbaijan`s aggressive plans against Armenia became possible in wake  of Pashinyan`s decisions on Artsakh - expert Azerbaijan`s aggressive plans against Armenia became possible in wake  of Pashinyan`s decisions on Artsakh - expert 
Zakharova: Russia sent a note of protest to Armenia over the act of  vandalism at the Zakharova: Russia sent a note of protest to Armenia over the act of  vandalism at the "Mother Armenia" memorial in Gyumri
Samvel Karapetyan proposes creating a post-election opposition coalitionSamvel Karapetyan proposes creating a post-election opposition coalition
Artsakh`s Cultural Heritage Ombudsman called on Moscow to respond to  destruction of WWII monuments by Azerbaijan in occupied NKRArtsakh`s Cultural Heritage Ombudsman called on Moscow to respond to  destruction of WWII monuments by Azerbaijan in occupied NKR
Prosecutor General`s Office  petitions Central Electoral Commission   for criminal prosecution of Robert KocharyanProsecutor General`s Office  petitions Central Electoral Commission   for criminal prosecution of Robert Kocharyan
Dutch Prime Minister expresses his support for Armenia`s democratic  reform and economic diversification agendaDutch Prime Minister expresses his support for Armenia`s democratic  reform and economic diversification agenda
 Heritage: It`s time for Armenia`s opposition to present people with  legitimate alternative to power Heritage: It`s time for Armenia`s opposition to present people with  legitimate alternative to power
RA Security Council Sec, Assistant to President of Azerbaijan hold  negotiations in Dilijan RA Security Council Sec, Assistant to President of Azerbaijan hold  negotiations in Dilijan 
CEC Neutralizes PAP: Three Political Forces to Enter Armenian Parliament Following Election VoteCEC Neutralizes PAP: Three Political Forces to Enter Armenian Parliament Following Election Vote