Thursday, October 12 2023 16:25

Thomas de Waal: President Aliyev had a choice, but he chose to use  force

Thomas de Waal: President Aliyev had a choice, but he chose to use  force

ArmInfo. The military operation marked the "formal end" of the Armenian-majority region of Nagorno-Karabakh, a  territorial entity that had existed under that name since 1923 and for centuries under other names. Thomas de Waal, scholar and writer, Senior Fellow at Carnegie Europe, the author of the famous book about the Karabakh conflict: "Black Garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan Through Peace and War", stated at a special PACE Hearing on the human rights and humanitarian situation of Karabakh Armenians and the international obligations of Azerbaijan.

As the specialist noted,  September 19th military assault by  Azerbaijan on Nagorno-Karabakh resulted in several hundred deaths  including civilians. This is a human tragedy, a tragedy of more than  100,000 people, since almost the entire Armenian population of  Nagorno-Karabakh fled to Armenia.

According to Thomas de Waal, the Karabakh conflict is very complex,  with many phases and turns. And for decades, it was force, not  diplomacy, that determined the outcomes "on the ground". Over the  years, many questions have arisen - both Armenians and Azerbaijanis  engaged in what can be described as ethnic cleansing. Recent events  are also a blow to the prospects for peace in the South Caucasus.

The specialist emphasized that this could have been avoided, as  active diplomatic efforts were made. Since December 2021, the West  has pursued an active diplomatic mediation process chaired by Charles  Michel, which has demanded greater input from all sides, particularly  from Azerbaijan, in parallel with negotiations between Armenia and  Azerbaijan mediated by Moscow.

In recent weeks, a dialogue has begun between the Armenians of  Karabakh and representatives of Baku, even despite the actual  blockade of Karabakh by Azerbaijan, which has caused "humanitarian  suffering" to the population of Karabakh. This new process between  the Armenians of Karabakh and Baku required time and patience.  Everyone, including the Armenians of Karabakh, understood that a  final settlement was possible within the framework of the territorial  integrity of Azerbaijan.

So, acting in the most dominant position, President Aliyev had a  choices but he chose to use force on September 19th. It also  undermined Western leaders' confidence in the process and interrupted  dialogue with the Armenians of Karabakh. And although a small number  of civilians were injured, as a result the entire Armenian population  no longer felt safe and left Karabakh.

We know that Azerbaijan's military operation was coordinated with  Turkey and, although we do not know any details, we can be fairly  sure that military actions were also coordinated with Russia. Russian  peacekeepers were ordered to stand down in Karabakh themselves,  allowing Azerbaijani forces to proceed and the media outlets were  instructed to blame Armenian Prime Minister Pashinyan, rather than  Azerbaijan, for the outbreak of this violence.

The UN and Moscow gave a much softer description of this military  operation than the West. And now the time has come for a  comprehensive reassessment of these events by organizations such as  PACE. Now Azerbaijan is proposing a "reintegration agenda", according  to which Armenians can return to Karabakh and become citizens of  Azerbaijan, taking into account that there is no dual citizenship in  Azerbaijan, and therefore renouncing Armenian citizenship. Therefore,  organizations like the Council of Europe should be very careful  regarding such initiatives. For example, why is this initiative being  proposed after 99% of the Armenians of Karabakh have already left  their land. This initiative should be considered within the broader  framework of Azerbaijan's international obligations.

In this context, three broader issues need to be addressed:

The first one concerns the general condition of minorities in  Azerbaijan. None of Azerbaijan's minorities have any special rights  or autonomy. The language of the two main minorities - Talysh and  Lezgin - iare taught to 28,000 children in schools, according to  Azerbaijani data for 2022. According to the Committee of the  Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities of  2017, national minorities are under pressure in the context of  demonstrating loyalty to the state. Also, national minorities do not  have the opportunity to fully express themselves in the public  sector. In this context, it is difficult to imagine the integration  of Armenians into Azerbaijani society.

The second point is, as the many independent reports have confirmed,  the Azerbaijani education system teaches children strongly negative  hatred towards Armenians as vandals and occupiers who committed  genocide against Azerbaijanis in the 1990s. It should be noted that  the Armenian education system does the same thing, just not as  actively. Therefore, without comprehensive reforms in the national  rhetoric (education system, political discourse and media) of  Azerbaijan, it is difficult to imagine a quiet life for Armenians in  Azerbaijan.

Thirdly, any such initiative requires careful study by the  international community, since Azerbaijan's record on this matter is  very poor. Despite many calls to Azerbaijan from the international  community for its representatives to visit Nagorno-Karabakh, all of  them were rejected by Azerbaijan. As a result, Nagorno- Karabakh  remained completely isolated, with only the ICRC on the ground. It is  known that the Parliamentary Assembly also called for a fact-finding  mission to be sent to Nagorno-Karabakh during the blockade in June,  but Azerbaijan rejected this call as well.

Thomas de Waal also spoke about the danger that threatens the  Armenian cultural heritage, mentioning the fact of the destruction  and complete liquidation of the rich and historically important  medieval cemetery in Julfa (Nakhichevan).

Azerbaijan, he said, also had a choice: a strong Armenia with  normalization of relations with Turkey and less dependence on Russia,  or a weak Armenia forced to rely more on Russia. Unfortunately,  Azerbaijan has opted for the second option. And this is not  accidental, since in this context the specialist mentioned Baku's  claims to the so-called on the territory of  Armenia and on the so-called . Thomas de Waal also  recalled Baku's claims to the territory of Armenia in the context of  the rhetoric about the so-called . 

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Opposition figure: The map of Armenia cannot be considered complete as long as the Azerbaijani army remains on our sovereign territoryOpposition figure: The map of Armenia cannot be considered complete as long as the Azerbaijani army remains on our sovereign territory
Head of the Ministry of Education, Culture and Research: the education system should also prepare young people to make decisions independentlyHead of the Ministry of Education, Culture and Research: the education system should also prepare young people to make decisions independently
Prime Minister: Today, the Armenian state is undergoing a phase of transformationPrime Minister: Today, the Armenian state is undergoing a phase of transformation
Pashinyan: One of the goals of the “Prime Minister’s Cup” tournament is to promote healthy competition among childrenPashinyan: One of the goals of the “Prime Minister’s Cup” tournament is to promote healthy competition among children
Tigran Abrahamyan: Those who disgrace the honor of the military uniform and epaulettes have become the face of the armyTigran Abrahamyan: Those who disgrace the honor of the military uniform and epaulettes have become the face of the army
A land plot on  Khatiss Street has been returned to the Abovyan communityA land plot on Khatiss Street has been returned to the Abovyan community
Armenia’s Ambassador to the United States Attended the Premiere of the Documentary Series “MELANIA: The Series”Armenia’s Ambassador to the United States Attended the Premiere of the Documentary Series “MELANIA: The Series”
The leader of the Mother Armenia party proposed that the Prime Minister of Armenia hold early elections to the National AssemblyThe leader of the Mother Armenia party proposed that the Prime Minister of Armenia hold early elections to the National Assembly
Interior Ministry: Armenian citizens who submitted applications are already receiving next-generation biometric passportsInterior Ministry: Armenian citizens who submitted applications are already receiving next-generation biometric passports
Rainy weather to return to Armenia, forecasters sayRainy weather to return to Armenia, forecasters say
The Yerevan Museum of Russian Art Turns 42The Yerevan Museum of Russian Art Turns 42
Five people were injured in a major traffic accident in Vanadzor.Five people were injured in a major traffic accident in Vanadzor.
Digital Solutions in the Foreign Exchange Market: IDBank and Rate.Trading at DigiTec 2026Digital Solutions in the Foreign Exchange Market: IDBank and Rate.Trading at DigiTec 2026
Digital Solutions in One Ecosystem: IDBank at DigiTec 2026               Digital Solutions in One Ecosystem: IDBank at DigiTec 2026            
MIA: one of the Ministry of Internal Affairs’ priorities is preventing crimes against minors and protecting their rightsMIA: one of the Ministry of Internal Affairs’ priorities is preventing crimes against minors and protecting their rights
Armenian authorities extend for another year the program of partial compensation for utility expenses of residents of border areasArmenian authorities extend for another year the program of partial compensation for utility expenses of residents of border areas
In Armenia, the maximum conscription age for students and postgraduate students at leading foreign universities who have received a military service deferment is proposed to be raised to 32.In Armenia, the maximum conscription age for students and postgraduate students at leading foreign universities who have received a military service deferment is proposed to be raised to 32.
Samvel Karapetyan: The opposition will remove Pashinyan from power without any dealsSamvel Karapetyan: The opposition will remove Pashinyan from power without any deals
The “Artsakh” Union demanded amendments to the law requiring “Azerbaijan” to be indicated in the “place of birth” field in Artsakh residents’ passports.The “Artsakh” Union demanded amendments to the law requiring “Azerbaijan” to be indicated in the “place of birth” field in Artsakh residents’ passports.
Zakharova: Neither Baku nor Yerevan has withdrawn its signatures from the 2020 trilateral agreementsZakharova: Neither Baku nor Yerevan has withdrawn its signatures from the 2020 trilateral agreements
A group of teachers held a protest outside Armenia’s Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sports over new certification rules.A group of teachers held a protest outside Armenia’s Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sports over new certification rules.
Armenia Interested in Swedish Experience in Managing Cultural InstitutionsArmenia Interested in Swedish Experience in Managing Cultural Institutions
Vahan Unanyan has been appointed head of the Armenian Embassy in Poland.Vahan Unanyan has been appointed head of the Armenian Embassy in Poland.
The total whitefish stock in Lake Sevan grew by 25.6% over the year.The total whitefish stock in Lake Sevan grew by 25.6% over the year.
President of Armenia appoints Samvel Mkrtchyan as the country’s new ambassador to RussiaPresident of Armenia appoints Samvel Mkrtchyan as the country’s new ambassador to Russia
Levon Ter-Petrosyan Responded to Pashinyan’s Attacks on a Female Journalist and Praised the Union of Journalists of ArmeniaLevon Ter-Petrosyan Responded to Pashinyan’s Attacks on a Female Journalist and Praised the Union of Journalists of Armenia
Armenia’s Prime Minister: We propose replacing the DNA of conflict with development, prosperity, freedom and independenceArmenia’s Prime Minister: We propose replacing the DNA of conflict with development, prosperity, freedom and independence
The Armenian side expressed condolences to the families of those killed in the explosion in TbilisiThe Armenian side expressed condolences to the families of those killed in the explosion in Tbilisi
Pashinyan: Draft of Armenia’s new Constitution to be published on November 23Pashinyan: Draft of Armenia’s new Constitution to be published on November 23
Armenian prisoners held in Baku have become honorary citizens of NiceArmenian prisoners held in Baku have become honorary citizens of Nice
The Head of Armenia’s Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sports Discussed Preparations for the European Gymnastics Championships in the Republic with International PartnersThe Head of Armenia’s Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sports Discussed Preparations for the European Gymnastics Championships in the Republic with International Partners
Armenia and Germany synchronize their watches on the bilateral cooperation agendaArmenia and Germany synchronize their watches on the bilateral cooperation agenda
Tigran Abrahamyan: The opposition is not afraid of pressure and will not allow the adoption of the “Aliyev Constitution”Tigran Abrahamyan: The opposition is not afraid of pressure and will not allow the adoption of the “Aliyev Constitution”
Using Hunger as a Weapon Is Genocide: American Congressman on the Blockade of ArtsakhUsing Hunger as a Weapon Is Genocide: American Congressman on the Blockade of Artsakh
Armenia’s Deputy Prime Minister and the Czech Ambassador note progress in implementing a number of joint projectsArmenia’s Deputy Prime Minister and the Czech Ambassador note progress in implementing a number of joint projects
Levon Kocharyan Responded to Pashinyan’s Insults Toward a Female JournalistLevon Kocharyan Responded to Pashinyan’s Insults Toward a Female Journalist
Germany’s Foreign Ministry summed up Wadephul’s visit to ArmeniaGermany’s Foreign Ministry summed up Wadephul’s visit to Armenia
The program for partially reimbursing pensioners’ expenses may be extended for three yearsThe program for partially reimbursing pensioners’ expenses may be extended for three years
The Secretary of Armenia’s Security Council Discussed Deepening Bilateral Cooperation with the Estonian AmbassadorThe Secretary of Armenia’s Security Council Discussed Deepening Bilateral Cooperation with the Estonian Ambassador
Meeting of the National Leader of the Turkmen People, Chairman of the Halk Maslahaty of Turkmenistan Hero-Arkadag with the Chairwoman of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian FederationMeeting of the National Leader of the Turkmen People, Chairman of the Halk Maslahaty of Turkmenistan Hero-Arkadag with the Chairwoman of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation
A memorial corner honoring Albert Hovhannisyan and other fallen heroes of the 44-day war will be established in Victory Park in Yerevan.A memorial corner honoring Albert Hovhannisyan and other fallen heroes of the 44-day war will be established in Victory Park in Yerevan.
IODA Calls on the Armenian Government to Stop Using the Law as a Political Tool Against the OppositionIODA Calls on the Armenian Government to Stop Using the Law as a Political Tool Against the Opposition
Armenia highlights the importance of creating and maintaining a unified register of missing persons.Armenia highlights the importance of creating and maintaining a unified register of missing persons.
Tigran Balayan Concludes Diplomatic Mission in BelgiumTigran Balayan Concludes Diplomatic Mission in Belgium
Lebedev described Yerevan and Baku’s desire to chair the CIS as a positive development.Lebedev described Yerevan and Baku’s desire to chair the CIS as a positive development.
The Migration and Citizenship Service “explained” why Azerbaijan is listed as the place of birth for refugees from ArtsakhThe Migration and Citizenship Service “explained” why Azerbaijan is listed as the place of birth for refugees from Artsakh
The Interior Minister discussed opportunities for cooperation with a number of countries in ReykjavikThe Interior Minister discussed opportunities for cooperation with a number of countries in Reykjavik
The 7th meeting of the Armenia-EU Partnership Committee was held in YerevanThe 7th meeting of the Armenia-EU Partnership Committee was held in Yerevan
Narek Karapetyan: Those who steal even a kopek from their homeland should be punished the same way children are punishedNarek Karapetyan: Those who steal even a kopek from their homeland should be punished the same way children are punished
SJA issued a statement regarding the incident involving a female journalist during the prime minister’s press conference.SJA issued a statement regarding the incident involving a female journalist during the prime minister’s press conference.
Starting in 2027, the A. Abrahamyan Museum of Russian Art will have its own restoration workshop.Starting in 2027, the A. Abrahamyan Museum of Russian Art will have its own restoration workshop.
Hakan Fidan: Turkey continues to do its part to ensure the peace treaty between Baku and Yerevan is signed as soon as possibleHakan Fidan: Turkey continues to do its part to ensure the peace treaty between Baku and Yerevan is signed as soon as possible
Former MP on Pashinyan’s statement: It is obvious that a new wave of repression is expected, traditionally accompanied by imprisonment and disgraceful campaignsFormer MP on Pashinyan’s statement: It is obvious that a new wave of repression is expected, traditionally accompanied by imprisonment and disgraceful campaigns
Armenia’s Deputy Minister of Internal Affairs Discussed Prospects for Developing Bilateral Relations with Austrian CounterpartsArmenia’s Deputy Minister of Internal Affairs Discussed Prospects for Developing Bilateral Relations with Austrian Counterparts
Putin, Trump and Xi Jinping adopted a joint declaration on peace following their meeting in ShenzhenPutin, Trump and Xi Jinping adopted a joint declaration on peace following their meeting in Shenzhen
ANC Deputy Chairman Makes Counterproposal to Pashinyan on Armenia’s New ConstitutionANC Deputy Chairman Makes Counterproposal to Pashinyan on Armenia’s New Constitution
Archbishop Bagrat will remain under house arrestArchbishop Bagrat will remain under house arrest
Journalistic organizations called for the withdrawal of an Armenian Justice Ministry bill establishing a minimum compensation threshold for insult and defamationJournalistic organizations called for the withdrawal of an Armenian Justice Ministry bill establishing a minimum compensation threshold for insult and defamation
Pashinyan to Participate in the G20 SummitPashinyan to Participate in the G20 Summit
National Assembly Deputy: Established Long-Term Cooperation with the WHO Is Becoming Increasingly CloseNational Assembly Deputy: Established Long-Term Cooperation with the WHO Is Becoming Increasingly Close
Read more



Commented